No two candidates are alike—and no single interview style works in every situation. To make better hiring decisions, employers need to look beyond gut instinct and conversational flow. By using the right mix of structured approaches and tools, you can uncover who a candidate really is—and how well they’ll perform in the role.
Here’s how to strengthen your interview strategy.
Choose the Right Interview Style for the Role
Different roles and situations call for different techniques. Here are four effective styles to consider:
1. Competency-Based (Behavioural) Interviews
Ask about real-life past experiences as predictors of future success.
Example: “Tell me about a time you had to manage conflicting priorities. What did you do, and what was the result?”
This style digs deep into actual behaviour—not hypothetical answers.
2. Situational Interviews
Pose hypothetical, job-related scenarios and assess the candidate’s thought process.
Example: “What would you do if a client demanded a rushed timeline that would compromise quality?”
Useful for roles that require critical thinking or frequent decision-making.
3. Life Theme Interviews
Explore broader life patterns and how they align with your organizational values or success models.
Best used when long-term cultural fit or motivation is a key factor.
4. Puzzler/Technical Questions
Test industry knowledge and mental agility with job-specific or logic-based challenges.
Example: “Walk me through how you’d troubleshoot an equipment breakdown on a tight deadline.”
Add Structure for Objectivity
No matter the style, structure matters. Here’s how to bring consistency to your interviews:
Use a set list of core questions for each candidate
Score answers on a scale (e.g., 1–5) based on job relevance
Take notes during or immediately after the interview
Involve multiple interviewers and compare observations
Structured interviews produce more reliable, fair, and legally defensible hiring decisions.
Use a Scorecard or Ranking System
A simple 1–5 scale allows you to rate each candidate on:
Required KSAs (knowledge, skills, and abilities)
Traits or style fit
Responses to scenario-based or behavioural questions
Overall alignment with role expectations
If more than one interviewer is involved, average your scores and discuss any major gaps in interpretation. This method balances qualitative impressions with structured evaluation.
Don’t Skip the Reference Checks
They’re more than a formality—references can validate your impressions or reveal red flags.
Tips:
Be clear about the role and context when speaking to referees
Listen not just to what is said, but how it’s said
Confirm key accomplishments and dig into areas of concern from the interview
Spend time on the candidate’s listed responsibilities—verify both scope and results
Final Thought
Interviewing isn’t just about asking questions—it’s about uncovering evidence. By using a mix of structured styles, tools, and evaluation methods, you’ll gain the insight you need to make confident, informed hiring decisions.
Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!
Job Analysis: Log Sheet
Understanding how employees spend their time is a key part of conducting an effective job analysis. This downloadable log sheet provides a simple, structured way to track daily tasks and responsibilities over a one-week READ MORE-->
Job Analysis: The Benefits of Job Analysis in Agriculture Recruitment
A job analysis is a structured review of a role’s duties, responsibilities, and requirements. It’s developed with input from incumbents, hiring managers, and HR to ensure alignment and accuracy across the hiring process. Importantly, READ MORE-->